90'+6' · 2nd

Second Half ends, New York City FC 1, Columbus Crew SC 0.

89' · 2nd

Substitution, New York City FC. Gary Mackay-Steven replaces Alexandru Mitrita.

88' · 2nd

Substitution, New York City FC. Gudmundur Thórarinsson replaces Jesús Medina because of an injury.

87' · 2nd

Substitution, New York City FC. Tony Rocha replaces Alexander Ring because of an injury.

83' · 2nd

Substitution, Columbus Crew SC. Harrison Afful replaces Chris Cadden.

71' · 2nd

Substitution, Columbus Crew SC. Fanendo Adi replaces Gyasi Zardes.

71' · 2nd

Substitution, New York City FC. Valentín Castellanos replaces Héber.

71' · 2nd

Substitution, Columbus Crew SC. Milton Valenzuela replaces Héctor Jiménez.