90'+6' · 2nd

Second Half ends, Columbus Crew 1, New York Red Bulls 2.

90'+2' · 2nd

Substitution, New York Red Bulls. Frankie Amaya replaces Cristian Cásseres Jr.

89' · 2nd

Substitution, New York Red Bulls. Tom Barlow replaces Patryk Klimala.

83' · 2nd

Substitution, Columbus Crew. Bradley Wright-Phillips replaces Pedro Santos.

77' · 2nd

Substitution, New York Red Bulls. John Tolkin replaces Fábio.

73' · 2nd

Substitution, Columbus Crew. Liam Fraser replaces Marlon Hairston.

73' · 2nd

Substitution, Columbus Crew. Alexandru Irinel Matan replaces Derrick Etienne.