104' · 5th

Penalty Shootout ends, New York Red Bulls 2(5), Columbus Crew 2(4).

90' · 5th

Penalty Shootout begins New York Red Bulls 2, Columbus Crew 2.

90'+14' · 2nd

Second Half ends, New York Red Bulls 2, Columbus Crew 2.

90'+4' · 2nd

Sean Nealis (New York Red Bulls) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.

90' · 2nd

Cucho Hernández (Columbus Crew) is shown the yellow card.

88' · 2nd

Substitution, New York Red Bulls. Elias Manoel replaces Lewis Morgan.

86' · 2nd

Substitution, Columbus Crew. Christian Ramirez replaces Rudy Camacho.